I judge people.
There.
I've said it.
I judge people who are rude to waiters.
I judge people who talk on speakerphone in public.
I judge people who don't return their shopping carts.
I judge people who arrive forty minutes late and walk in holding an iced coffee.
Because now I have questions.
You had time for cold foam, but not for me?
I judge the person having a full FaceTime conversation in the airport lounge.
I judge couples who spend an entire dinner looking at their phones.
I judge people who leave their hotel rooms looking like a minor burglary occurred.
And yes, occasionally, I judge an outfit.
Not every thought needs to become a statement about someone's character.
Sometimes the pants are simply terrible.
And I couldn't help but wonder:
When did noticing things about people become something we're supposed to pretend we don't do?
Everyone Is Judging Everyone
We seem to have developed a very strange social agreement.
We all judge.
But we're supposed to pretend we don't.
We observe how people speak.
How they treat their partners.
How they treat strangers.
Whether they show up.
Whether they keep promises.
Whether they tip.
Whether they gossip.
Whether they listen.
Whether they make every conversation about themselves.
And then we take all that information and make decisions.
Do I trust this person?
Do I want to work with them?
Would I lend them money?
Would I invite them to dinner?
Would I let them date my friend?
Would I ever willingly share a hotel room with them?
That last one reveals more about a relationship than almost anything else.
Call it judgment.
Call it discernment.
Call it pattern recognition.
Whatever makes everyone comfortable.
But we're doing it.
Some Things Deserve Judgment
There is a difference between judging someone for wearing the wrong shoes and judging someone for treating people badly.
One is taste.
The other is information.
If someone is consistently cruel to service workers, I am going to notice.
If someone cheats every time they're in a relationship, I'm going to factor that into how much I trust their relationship advice.
If someone tells me everyone they've ever known is "toxic," I may eventually become curious about the common denominator.
If someone borrows money and posts from Cabo before paying it back—
I'm judging.
Quite confidently, actually.
We're constantly told not to judge people because we don't know what they're going through.
That's true.
Context matters.
Compassion matters.
People have terrible days.
But understanding someone's behavior doesn't always require pretending the behavior is acceptable.
Sometimes people aren't misunderstood.
Sometimes they're being an asshole.
We Confused Acceptance With Approval
This might be where things got complicated.
We're supposed to accept people as they are.
I agree.
But accepting who someone is doesn't mean I have to approve of everything they do.
You're allowed to live however you want.
And I'm allowed to think it's a terrible idea.
Those two things can coexist beautifully.
You can date him again.
I can think you shouldn't.
You can spend $1,800 on a handbag while carrying credit-card debt.
I can admire the handbag and question the financial strategy.
You can quit your job to become a wellness influencer in Bali.
I can wish you tremendous success while privately wondering whether we have enough wellness influencers in Bali.
Acceptance means understanding that other adults get to make their own decisions.
It doesn't require us to lose all opinions about them.
And Yes, Sometimes It's Shallow
Let's not make this too noble.
Sometimes judgment has absolutely nothing to do with character.
Sometimes we're sitting at dinner and someone walks past wearing something questionable.
Our friend looks at us.
We look at our friend.
Nobody says anything.
Nobody needs to.
Was it spiritually evolved?
Probably not.
Was anyone harmed?
Also no.
Humans are observant.
We notice beautiful things.
We notice strange things.
We notice when someone is wildly overdressed.
We notice when someone is wildly underdressed.
We notice the couple arguing three tables away while pretending we aren't listening.
We notice.
The important question isn't whether the thought entered our head.
It's what we do with it afterward.
Judgment Becomes Ugly When It Needs an Audience
This is where I think the line actually is.
Thinking something isn't the same as humiliating someone.
Having standards isn't the same as cruelty.
Not liking someone's choices doesn't give us permission to make them feel small.
There is an enormous difference between thinking:
That dress isn't doing anything for her.
And walking over to tell her.
Please don't.
She didn't ask.
There is a difference between realizing a friend's relationship looks unhealthy and gleefully discussing every detail with six other people.
There is a difference between noticing someone is struggling and using their struggle to feel superior.
Good judgment should help us navigate our own lives.
Bad judgment turns someone else's life into entertainment.
Your Friends Are Supposed to Judge You a Little
This may be controversial.
I want friends who occasionally judge me.
Not constantly.
That sounds exhausting.
But if I'm making an obviously terrible decision, I don't want everyone sitting around saying:
"Whatever makes you happy."
Excuse me?
I've known you for fifteen years.
Participate.
If I'm about to text someone I absolutely should not text, take the phone.
If I'm being unreasonable, tell me.
If I've complained about the same situation for six months while refusing to change anything, eventually I deserve a raised eyebrow.
If an outfit is truly terrible and we're leaving for dinner, I expect intervention.
That's friendship.
Sometimes love sounds less like unconditional validation and more like:
"I adore you. Absolutely not."
Maybe We Need Better Judgment, Not Less of It
Judgment protects us.
It helps us choose partners.
Friends.
Employees.
Business partners.
People we trust with our children.
People we trust with our secrets.
People we absolutely do not invite on vacation again.
We should question our judgments.
We should ask whether they're based on prejudice, insecurity, jealousy or simply unfamiliarity.
We should change our minds when we get new information.
We should give people room to surprise us.
But pretending we shouldn't judge anything isn't kindness.
It's impossible.
Maybe the goal isn't to become people without judgment.
Maybe it's to become people with better judgment.
Less interested in whether someone's shoes are expensive.
More interested in whether they're kind.
Less impressed by status.
More impressed by integrity.
Less concerned with whether someone's life looks correct.
More interested in whether the way they live it hurts other people.
And perhaps occasionally still wondering why they wore that to a wedding.
We're only human.
And I couldn't help but wonder:
Maybe being judgmental isn't the problem. Maybe the problem is that we've gotten very good at judging things that don't matter—and remarkably bad at judging the things that do.
0 comments